Cody Rhodes has been a babyface since he returned to WWE at WrestleMania 38 in 2022. He’s been teasing a heel turn for a while, but it hasn’t happened yet. Now, we finally know why.
Last year, Rhodes hinted at turning heel multiple times during his rivalry with John Cena. This year too, he almost turned heel while feuding with Randy Orton.
At Crown Jewel, the American Nightmare finally punt-kicked Randy Orton to defeat him, proving that he’s not afraid to tap into his darker side. It seemed as if he would then fully embrace his villainous persona, but alas, fans were disappointed again.
According to WrestleVotes on Fightful Select, Rhodes’ heel turn in WWE hasn’t materialized yet, because many key people within TKO, WWE’s parent company, are “strongly” against the idea, despite “potential storyline implications.”
“There are several key people within TKO, at a minimum, who are strongly opposed to the idea of Cody Rhodes turning heel, regardless of any potential storyline implications, @WrestleVotes Radio on @FightfulSelect has learned.”
There are several key people within TKO, at a minimum, who are strongly opposed to the idea of Cody Rhodes turning heel, regardless of any potential storyline implications, @WrestleVotes Radio on @FightfulSelect has learned.
A LOT more details are now available on Select for subscribers.
— Fightful Wrestling (@Fightful) November 19, 2026
Cody Rhodes’ babyface run has been a massive success, but now fans have gotten bored. The WWE Universe wants more than just a typical babyface Cody Rhodes vs. a heel star storyline. The fans want to see him turn heel.
This was evident during Rhodes’ rivalry with Orton. Fans were cheering for Orton despite him being a heel and jeering at babyface Rhodes. But it looks like it’s going to be a while before that happens.
Cody Rhodes To Lead Team America At Survivor Series
For now, Cody Rhodes is still a babyface, unlike what fans have been demanding. He’s set to captain Team America at the upcoming 5-on-5 traditional Survivor Series elimination match. CM Punk, Je’Von Evans, and LA Knight will fight from his corner. One more star is yet to be added to the team.
The last member of Rhodes’ team will be announced on the November 20 edition of Friday Night SmackDown. The former Undisputed WWE Champion recently logged onto his Instagram account to hype the upcoming SmackDown episode. He promoted the show, revealing that he’s going to reveal the last member of his Team America.
Rhodes’ team will face Team Mexico, which comprises Rey Mysterio, the team captain, Penta, Rey Fénix, Dragon Lee, and one more star (to be announced).
Also Read: Jeff Hardy Says WWE Return Is ‘Inevitable,’ Wants CM Punk Match