Ilia Topuria’s devastating defeat to Justin Gaethje at UFC Freedom 250 left more lasting consequences than initially expected. The former lightweight champion suffered two broken orbital bones, a shattered septum, and a broken foot during the June 14 encounter, raising serious questions about how much damage his body can withstand.
Although Topuria has recovered from those injuries, he remains unable to resume full-contact training. The Spaniard has floated the possibility of returning in April 2027 to face Paddy Pimblett, but no official announcement has been made.
More concerning, however, was his revelation that he came dangerously close to undergoing surgery for his damaged orbital bones. Doctors would have needed to insert titanium plates beneath the affected tissue, potentially putting an end to his fighting career. Topuria reportedly avoided the procedure by a margin of just 0.5 millimeters.
Given how close he came to a career-threatening operation, another punishment-heavy fight at lightweight could be a major risk. Joe Rogan appears to share those concerns, as the UFC commentator believes Topuria should abandon the 155-pound division and return to featherweight.
Topuria’s struggles with making the featherweight limit have been well documented, ultimately prompting his move to 155lbs. Since suffering the first defeat of his professional MMA career, the Spaniard has called for an immediate rematch with Gaethje for the lightweight title while also expressing interest in settling his rivalry with Paddy Pimblett.
However, Rogan believes Topuria would be better suited to competing at 145lbs. The UFC commentator feels that while the former two-division champion possesses exceptional technical abilities, he lacks the natural size to compete comfortably against elite lightweights. Discussing Topuria on a recent episode of his podcast, Rogan said, “He was head and shoulders above everybody and technically.”
He further praised the Spaniard’s overall approach to fighting, adding, “So like, the efficiency of his movement and the power of his strikes and the confidence and the discipline, like, that mother****** dials everything in for a fight, he’d just never been in the trenches.”
Rogan then pointed to the physical disparity between Topuria and Gaethje as another reason why the Spaniard might struggle at lightweight.
He explained, “First of all, Gaethje’s bigger than him, like quite a bit bigger than him, Gaethje’s a big guy, he’s a big 155lber and Ilia is not, you know. And that’s a factor too, he probably should be 145lbs. At 145lbs, he’s a motherf******, at 155lbs, it’s like some of those guys. There’s a difference… It seems like it’s only 10lbs but it’s not.”
Fighters routinely cut weight before weigh-ins to gain a size advantage after rehydrating. However, Topuria has previously made it clear that he has no intention of putting himself through the physically demanding process of cutting down to 145lbs again.
Rogan, nevertheless, remains convinced that featherweight is where Topuria could be at his most dangerous. Reiterating his stance, he said, “I think with Ilia, at 145lbs, it’s a much better weight class for him. But I’m interested to see when he comes back and how he rebounds from something like that.”
With Topuria eyeing a return in 2027, his next move will be worth watching. Whether he chooses to remain at lightweight and pursue unfinished business with Gaethje or Pimblett, or finally considers a return to featherweight, the former UFC double champion has some major decisions to make.