Ryan Garcia’s Dilemma: Legacy Against Teofimo Lopez or Payday Against Floyd Mayweather?

Sami Haider
6 Min Read
Ryan Garcia steps onto the scale ahead of a fight Photo: IMAGO / Hoganphotos

Ryan Garcia has been one of the most talked-about and hyped names in boxing lately. The 28-year-old WBC welterweight champion (26-2, 21 KOs) comes off a dominant 2026. He took the title from Mario Barrios in February and demolished Conor Benn in September. Now he has set the boxing world buzzing again. Garcia has named Feb. 6 as his target date for a return to the ring.

The trouble starts with the two opponents he put on the table. Both offers are unsigned, and they sit at opposite ends of the sport. On one side is Teofimo Lopez (23-2), the new WBA champion and one of the most dangerous fighters of this generation. On the other is Floyd Mayweather Jr. (50-0), a 49-year-old living legend who has not fought a professional bout in nine years.

Garcia must decide whether he wants to build his boxing legacy or take the biggest paycheck.

Teofimo Lopez Unification Would Give Ryan Garcia Real Title Credibility

A bout with “The Takeover” would unify the WBC and WBA titles, making the winner the absolute top of the 147-pound class. The Ring currently ranks Garcia No. 2 and Lopez No. 3 at welterweight.

Lopez became a three-division champion after winning the WBA belt via a majority decision over Rolando Romero on August 22, bouncing back from a junior welterweight title loss to Shakur Stevenson in January. Winning this matchup would give “KingRy” ultimate boxing credibility and make him the undisputed face of the division. 

ALSO READ: Ryan Garcia Wants Rematch at 147 But Says Gervonta Davis Is ‘Little Bit Scared’

Right at this moment, advanced talks are already targeting New York or Las Vegas for Feb. 6. Reporter Mike Coppinger noted on X that he “would be surprised if Garcia-Teofimo didn’t take place next.” The main obstacle is the WBA ordering Lopez to face mandatory challenger Jack Catterall. 

However, Coppinger also reported that neither the WBA’s decision nor the possibility of a Mayweather fight is expected to interfere with the discussions, making the Lopez fight the current industry frontrunner.

Despite the operational momentum behind the Lopez fight, Garcia showed how open the choice remains during a video filmed inside his SUV alongside his young daughters.  When Garcia asked, “Who would you want me to fight?”, the girls picked Lopez, though one playfully suggested NBA superstar LeBron James. 

However, their suggestion couldn’t help him settle a real business decision because their bout would likely net Garcia a guaranteed purse in line with his recent outings, such as his $20 million payday against Rolando Romero. 

Floyd Mayweather Fight Would Pay Ryan Garcia Big 

In contrast, a fight with Mayweather takes the financial stakes to an entirely different tier.  Historical metrics justify the massive valuation.

Ceremonial weigh-in ahead of Floyd Mayweather v John Gotti III in Mexico MEXICO CITY, MEXICO - AUGUST 23: Floyd Mayweather poses for photos during the ceremonial weigh-in ahead of his exhibition fight against John Gotti III , in Mexico City, Mexico on August 23, 2024. Mexico World. Editorial use only. Please get in touch for any other usage. PUBLICATIONxNOTxINxTURxUSAxCANxUKxJPNxITAxFRAxAUSxESPxBELxKORxRSAxHKGxNZL Copyright: x2025xAnadoluxDanielxCardenasx
Undefeated boxing icon Floyd Mayweather remains the ultimate box-office draw. Photo: IMAGO / Anadolu Agency

Mayweather’s 2017 fight with Conor McGregor drew 4.3 million North American pay-per-view buys, second only to his 2015 win over Manny Pacquiao at 4.6 million. These benchmarks show why a matchup with “Money” is a cash cow.

Garcia’s attorney, Guadalupe Valencia, confirmed to The Ring that they are only discussing a professional bout, not an exhibition. To make it happen, Mayweather must put his 50-0 record on the line for the first time since 2017. 

Industry experts estimate Mayweather’s payout could start at $50 million and reach $100 million after pay-per-view and sponsorship cuts, with Garcia clear to earn a massive, career-high payday as well if the fight happens.

However, the matchup remains highly unlikely for the immediate future, although Matchroom Boxing promoter Eddie Hearn recently claimed that “the fight is on.” But from a boxing standpoint, beating a 49-year-old fighter who has been retired for nearly a decade adds nothing to Garcia’s active championship credentials. 

So, he must decide for himself whether he wants to build his boxing legacy or take the biggest check.

Share This Article